What Are the Most Painful Piercings?

Pain is one of the biggest questions people have before getting a new piercing — and we get it! Everyone experiences pain differently, but understanding what to expect can make the process way less intimidating. At Identity Body Piercing, we believe that being informed helps you feel confident and in control. So, let’s break down which piercings tend to be more sensitive and why.

Understanding Piercing Pain

Pain during a piercing is quick — it usually lasts only a few seconds. What you’re feeling is the needle passing through skin, cartilage, or tissue. Afterward, you might experience some tenderness or a dull ache, but this fades as your piercing heals. Factors like your individual pain tolerance, the location of the piercing, and your piercer’s technique all play a role.

Most Painful Piercings (According to Most Clients)

Here are some of the piercings that tend to rank higher on the pain scale:

🔹 Daith Piercing

Located in the inner fold of cartilage above your ear canal, the daith is thick and dense. It can create a sharp pinch followed by pressure — but the result is totally worth it if you love a bold, hidden statement piece.

🔹 Rook Piercing

The rook passes through a firm ridge of cartilage inside the ear. It’s small but mighty — many clients describe it as a “deep pressure” type of pain that quickly fades once the jewelry is in place.

🔹 Industrial Piercing

This piercing connects two holes in the upper ear cartilage with a barbell. Because it involves two piercings in one session, you’ll feel two separate stings, plus some soreness as it heals. It’s one of the coolest ear projects but does require patience and diligent aftercare.

🔹 Septum Piercing

While it looks intimidating, a septum piercing isn’t as bad as people think — if it’s done correctly through the “sweet spot,” a thin membrane of tissue just below the cartilage. If you’ve got that spot, the pain is quick and more of a sneezy, teary-eye moment than a lasting pain.

🔹 Nipple Piercings

These are sensitive areas by nature, and the piercing process can deliver a strong pinch. However, many clients say the sensation is over before they realize it — and the aesthetic payoff makes it a favorite among our boldest clients.

🔹 Genital Piercings

These top the pain list simply because of the nerve density and sensitivity in the area. These piercings require an experienced piercer and thorough consultation before proceeding.

Less Painful (But Still Stunning) Options

If you’re pain-averse but still want to get pierced, consider:

Lobes – classic, quick, and minimal discomfort.

Helix – outer cartilage, a short pinch.

Nostril – a brief sting and maybe a tear or two.

Pain vs. Payoff

At the end of the day, every piercing has a moment of discomfort, but that moment is temporary — the sparkle you get to wear every day is not. Our piercers at Identity Body Piercing are experts at making the process safe, smooth, and as comfortable as possible. We walk you through every step, help you breathe through the moment, and ensure you leave feeling empowered and stylish.

Ready to test your pain tolerance (safely)?

Book your next piercing appointment at Identity Body Piercing in Wicker Park or Roscoe Village. Walk-ins welcome daily from 12–8 PM.

✨ Identity Body Piercing – Chicago’s Queen Bee of Piercings.