When Can I Switch to a Hoop in My New Piercing? What to Know Before Making the Change

At Identity Body Piercing, one of the most common questions we hear is: “When can I switch to a hoop?”​

Hoops are beloved for their stylish, minimalist look, and they’re often the end goal for many piercing clients. But here’s the truth: timing matters—and changing too early can lead to irritation, delayed healing, or worse, infection.

Let’s break down when it’s safe to switch to a hoop depending on your piercing type:

💫 Earlobe Piercings

Average healing time: 6–8 weeks

When to switch: After 2–3 months, if fully healed

Earlobes are among the fastest-healing piercings, but don’t let that fool you—everyone’s body is different. Even if it “feels fine,” it’s best to wait a full 2–3 months before swapping to a hoop. We recommend coming in for a check-up first—our piercers can confirm if your piercing is ready.

💫 Helix Piercings

Average healing time: 6–12 months

When to switch: After 6 months minimum—and only if there’s no tenderness, swelling, or discharge

Cartilage piercings like the helix heal more slowly. Hoops can introduce movement and pressure that interfere with healing, so it’s important not to rush. If you’re still bumping it or sleeping on that side, stick with a stud for a bit longer.

💫 Conch Piercings

Average healing time: 6–12 months

When to switch: After 6–9 months with no signs of irritation

A hoop in a conch can look stunning—but it also requires a longer, more cautious healing period. Inner ear piercings are prone to swelling and pressure issues, especially if you’re using headphones or earbuds. Your piercer will let you know when you’re ready for the upgrade.

💫 Nostril Piercings

Average healing time: 3–6 months

When to switch: After 3–4 months, if healed cleanly

Nostril piercings typically heal faster than cartilage but can be sneaky—what seems healed on the outside might still be fragile underneath. If you’re dreaming of a dainty nose hoop, be patient and avoid switching too soon. Even a small snag can re-open the piercing.

So… how do you know it’s really healed?

A healed piercing should be: ✔️ Free of redness and swelling ✔️ No tenderness or soreness to the touch ✔️ No crust or discharge ✔️ Not reactive to movement or pressure

Why hoops can be tricky early on

Hoops tend to move more and can rotate, creating micro-tears or irritation in a piercing that’s still settling. They also offer less stability than a stud, which can increase your chances of bumps or delayed healing.

Be patient, not pierced twice

We know you’re excited to rock that new hoop—and we’re excited for you, too! But trust the process and wait until your piercing is fully healed. When in doubt, come by either our Wicker Park or Roscoe Village studios for a check-in. We’re here to help you transition safely and stylishly 💎

Need help upgrading to a hoop?

Walk-ins are welcome every day from 12–8 PM, or you can book a jewelry change with one of our piercers. We’ll help you find the perfect fit for your style and your anatomy.

Roscoe Village: 2256 W Belmont Ave Chicago, IL 60618

Wicker Park: 1514 N Ashland Ave Chicago, IL 60622